According to the article, "Woolly Mammoth Sparks Debate Over Cloning" by Joyce Grant, should the woolly mammoth be cloned? Cite two pieces of evidence from the text to support the claim.
Final answer: The article presents arguments for and against cloning Woolly Mammoths. Proponents argue it could potentially repair some ecological damage while opponents caution about ethical implications and potential health problems for the cloned species. Whether the Woolly Mammoth should be cloned remains a matter of personal perspective and ethics.
The article 'Woolly Mammoth Sparks Debate Over Cloning' by Joyce Grant elicits a controversial debate about the ethics and feasibility of cloning Woolly Mammoths. While the article does not explicitly advocate for or against the process, it presents arguments from both sides.
Evidence From Proponents:
1. Ecological Benefits: Proponents of cloning the Woolly Mammoth argue that it could be a profound scientific achievement with potential environmental benefits. They suggest that reintroducing mammoths into certain ecosystems could help break down dead plants, promoting new growth and positively impacting the climate.
2. Repairing Ecological Damage: Another piece of evidence is that mammoths have been suggested to aid in repairing ecological damage caused by human activities. By reintroducing mammoths, proponents believe they can help restore balance to certain habitats.
Evidence From Opponents:
1. Ethical Implications: Opponents of cloning the Woolly Mammoth raise concerns about the ethical implications of bringing back an extinct species. They argue that manipulating nature in this way raises questions about the sanctity of life and the potential consequences of playing "creator."
2. Health Problems and Ecosystem Fit: Another point made by opponents is the potential health problems that cloned mammoths could face and the challenges they might encounter fitting into modern ecosystems. They highlight the risks and uncertainties associated with reviving these extinct creatures.
Based on the evidence presented by both sides, the decision of whether the Woolly Mammoth should be cloned ultimately comes down to personal perspective and ethical considerations. It is crucial to weigh the scientific curiosity and potential environmental benefits against the ethical concerns and unforeseen consequences that may arise.